Join 924 investors who get actionable, evidenced-based wealth management insights delivered directly to their inbox.

Active Arguments Disproved

A reader asked me to comment on a recent Forbes article titled “Active Versus Passive Management: Which Is Better?” The author, contributor Peter Andersen, asks this question while observing that, in 2014, the vast majority of active fund managers underperformed the S&P 500 Index.

However, he also notes that there have been periods “where active management of large-cap equity funds stunningly outperformed simple indexing.”

Andersen, who is the chief investment officer at Congress Wealth Management, presents a graph in which he demonstrates “evidence” showing the percentage of active managers who outperformed the passive S&P 500 index investor each year. His graph shows various periods since 1989 when active managers outperform the S&P 500. I thought I’d share my response.

Read the rest of the article on


We want to hear from you!


200 Commerce Street
Suite 300
Montgomery, AL 36104


304 Jamestown Boulevard
Dothan, AL 36301

Receive Our Newsletter